I love oatmeal raisin cookies and gingersnaps as much as the next gal, but I like to look for cookie recipes that are a bit out of the ordinary too. Show up at a party with a batch of maple-glazed maple cookies and you’ll put smiles on a lot of faces! Plus, they’re a gorgeous bake. The maple glaze—made with a combo of butter, confectioners’ sugar and maple syrup—helps set the cookies apart, both visually and in terms of flavor.
Maple Cookie Ingredients
- Butter: Either salted or unsalted butter will work in this maple cookie recipe. Use a brand with a nice, rich dairy flavor. To add an extra Vermont-y touch, use the butter that Ina Garten loves.
- Sugars: This recipe calls for three types of sugar: granulated sugar, brown sugar and confectioners’ sugar. Granulated sugar is the standby for use in baked goods, brown sugar adds a delicious molasses flavor, and confectioners’ sugar is perfect for smooth homemade frosting and icing.
- Eggs: If you have access to local or free-range eggs, those are always a good bet for baking.
- Maple flavoring: For the best flavor, seek out natural rather than imitation maple flavoring. If you can’t find maple flavoring, real vanilla is a fine substitute, although you could also use real maple syrup.
- Flour: There are many different types of flour, and for this maple cookie recipe, you’ll need regular old all-purpose.
- Baking soda: Baking soda is often included in cookie recipes because it promotes browning.
- Salt: In desserts, adding enough salt is crucial to achieving a balanced flavor, so don’t be shy.
- White baking chips: White chocolate chips are creamy and mild, pairing well with lots of different flavors. Check out the maple cookie recipe variations below for other baking chips that are a great match for this treat.
- Pecans: South meets north when you mix pecans and maple syrup, and the results are delicious.
- Maple syrup: Maple syrup is made by simmering sap from sugar maple trees until it has reduced and caramelized. The flavor is unlike any of the imitation maple pancake syrups, so make sure you’re buying the real thing.
Taste of Home
Find more recipes like this on my companion blog, “Good Food, Good Meat, Good God, Let’s Eat!”


